Fullrange and passive radiator

Hello, I'm wondering, because I didn't saw much of this kind of speaker here. I mean compact speakers with a fullrange and a passive radiator. Is this something completelly off the charts ? Something not effective at all ?

Here are the two projects I made around this idea.

IMG_20230430_120112.jpg
IMG_20230430_120129.jpg

-Spherical enclosure made of blanda bowls (2.4L inside) ;
-Dayton Audio RS100-4 fullrange driver direct wired and no filter;
-Dayton Audio DSA115 Passive radiator.

IMG_20240223_112455.jpg
IMG_20240223_112623.jpg

-Pill shaped enclosure made of blanda bowls and layers of MDF (8.6L inside);
-Markaudio Alpair 11MS fullrange driver, direct wired and no filter;
-SB Acoustics SB15SFCR-00 5'' x 8'' passive radiator.

Thank you in advance for your replies on the subject.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
frugal-phile™
Joined 2001
Paid Member
A PR is just a vent substitute (with an additional suspension resonance).

Usually used with a small box and a vent that would otherwise be too long. That would not be the case with the pill shaped one — as cracked case says, interesting shape.

Here the 9 litre CGR for the A11ms, you can see the vent is not overlong.

https://frugal-phile.com/boxlib/P10free/CGR-dMK11-180820.pdf

dave
 
Hello, I'm wondering, because I didn't saw much of this kind of speaker here. I mean compact speakers with a fullrange and a passive radiator. Is this something completelly off the charts ? Something not effective at all ?

Here are the two projects I made around this idea.


-Spherical enclosure made of blanda bowls (2.4L inside) ;
-Dayton Audio RS100-4 fullrange driver direct wired and no filter;
-Dayton Audio DSA115 Passive radiator.


-Pill shaped enclosure made of blanda bowls and layers of MDF (8.6L inside);
-Markaudio Alpair 11MS fullrange driver, direct wired and no filter;
-SB Acoustics SB15SFCR-00 5'' x 8'' passive radiator.

Thank you in advance for your replies on the subject.
Brilliant execution.
I think passive radiators are the much better option when you have a driver that's happier in a vented box, but you don't like the sound of a vented box (like me).
Check out Buchardt Audio, https://buchardtaudio.com/, or maybe you already know their products.
One thing I would try to do with a PR is fit it at the back if possible.