Madisound vs Hi-Vi Speakers

[upking]

Hey guys, wassup?
I'm trying to choose between those 2 speakers:
Hi-Vi:
Hi-Vi L6-6R 6" Woven Kevlar Cone Woofer - 6 ohm: Madisound Speaker Store

Madisound:
Madisound 6102-8 6" Polypropylene Cone Woofer: Madisound Speaker Store

I'll built a 2Way Bookshelf with one of them also I've made some simulations

Gain:

An externally hosted image should be here but it was not working when we last tested it.

Group Delay:

An externally hosted image should be here but it was not working when we last tested it.

As we can see, the madisound speaker has a better response below 60hz, I'm trying to get as much as possible from the bass cause I'd like to listen to music without my subwoofer.

Also I'm trying to have a flat response from the speakers so that I gain quality, that's what really matters in my system.

Are the madisound speakers a good choice? what else should I look before buying a speaker?
If you have any suggestion please share with me. Anything below $60.
I'm also accepting suggestions for tweeters to use with those drivers.

Thanks again! Cya!

 

[pski]

Hey guys, wassup?
I'm trying to choose between those 2 speakers:
Hi-Vi:
Hi-Vi L6-6R 6" Woven Kevlar Cone Woofer - 6 ohm: Madisound Speaker Store

Madisound:
Madisound 6102-8 6" Polypropylene Cone Woofer: Madisound Speaker Store

I'll built a 2Way Bookshelf with one of them also I've made some simulations

Gain:

Group Delay:

As we can see, the madisound speaker has a better response below 60hz, I'm trying to get as much as possible from the bass cause I'd like to listen to music without my subwoofer.

Also I'm trying to have a flat response from the speakers so that I gain quality, that's what really matters in my system.

Are the madisound speakers a good choice? what else should I look before buying a speaker?
If you have any suggestion please share with me. Anything below $60.
I'm also accepting suggestions for tweeters to use with those drivers.

Thanks again! Cya!

I don't see a $25 woofer having a vas of 56 L unless . .

 

[upking]

unless...? didn't got the point of it. Sorry =(

 

[Lojzek]

Hey guys, wassup?
I'm trying to choose between those 2 speakers: Hi-Vi and Madisound:
I'll built a 2Way Bookshelf with one of them also I've made some simulations

Hi,

Looking at Madisound driver reminds me of similar cheap drivers
that I've worked with and I can tell you to prepare yourself in case
you get one to get totally different parameters if you measure them.

Magnet installed in Madisound can't possibly give you Qt =0,35.
There is a great possibility you will have to count on making a sealed
box for good bass performance. HiVi looks better.

My