Is any of these 2 xover technically preferable?

How i make a "polar plots" ?
Right click the directivity plot and choose polar map. Right click on the impedance plot and choose directivity chart. Right click on the impedance plot and choose polar map.

And can i use the measurements from 2 days ago to "make polar" ?
You have changed 'Y' for the crossover. The polar map will show this difference now, even if you don't measure at many angles.

If my cabinette is 230 mm wide with rounded corners, and the WG is 175 mm wide placed in the middle.
What is the X axis ? (115 mm ?)
0
 
No it doesn't. But my bet is that the more point source, the better image. I see a true point source as the "grail"- yes hyper smooth, even, 360 omni. I will attempt to build a pair in one way I haven't tried yet 🙂 - with a big nod to Amar. But there is a distinct difference between the HornFlower and my corner floor2ceiling line sources for sure - that are since a few days at the same location for the first time. Advantage HF.

Sorry for the OT - the mod started it ;-D

//
 
I feel now I might probably have misunderstood you or written something offending. I don't grasp the gist of "Remind me..." - sorry for my limited language skills. For the rest of #24 I cant tie the comments to what I wrote in #23. Sorry again and I hope you didn't found the "mod" comment insulting in any way...

/
 
Right click the directivity plot and choose polar map. Right click on the impedance plot and choose directivity chart. Right click on the impedance plot and choose polar map.
Here is the simulations for the xover. (think i mixed them up before, my head was spinning after a long day)

Named Polar 1 is just the xover with our settings.
Polar 1 inverted tweeter, is the same but with inverted tweeter.
Polar 2 is the same BUT with all drivers unmuted.
Polar 3 is the same but with 24 dB on midrange insted of 12 dB (as polar 1)

Can you see something on this polars ?
For me its just like a rainbow but not as pretty.
 

Attachments

  • Polar1.png
    Polar1.png
    806.6 KB · Views: 6
  • Polar2.png
    Polar2.png
    855.5 KB · Views: 6
  • Polar1 inverted tweeter.png
    Polar1 inverted tweeter.png
    852.1 KB · Views: 4
  • Polar3.png
    Polar3.png
    833.1 KB · Views: 6