Preamp board, is this a good design to build?

I've been looking for a decent tone control preamp and have tried a couple Chinese boards that were awful. I was considering the ESP HiFi preamp but this was deemed a poor design as discussed on a different post.
This is another board kit I found which has decent specs. The balance control was added by me but not sure if that's the optimal location.

K8084 preamp schematic.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Moderator
Joined 2011
On the first op amp, the gain is wrongly set.
The feedback resistor should be the larger one, and the resistor to ground is the smaller one.
But their ratio is typically around ten rather than 100.

The balance control cannot work as shown.
 
The balance circuit shorts the output of the opamps at the ends of the potentiometer range, and since the output impedance of an opamp is measured in milliohms (at low frequencies at least), the balance pot is doing nothing but overloading those opamps at the ends of the range. Perhaps the balance pot was originally connected to the wipers of the volume pots, which makes sense.

Modern low-noise design typically uses lower resistance values, like 10k pots, to help push the noise floor as low as possible.

Using a Baxandall volume stage at the input would cancel the inversion of the tone-control stage, but would require a difference balance circuit.